So, I broke my Project 10 Pan no-buy. Is anybody surprised?! I picked this mascara up in Boots after seeing a bit of a buzz about it online and being curious about the 'lengthening fibres' as I've not used a fibre mascara before.
The packaging is pretty cute, I must admit. I really like the cheekiness of it without it becoming smutty and too much. The top also 'click's into place which is pretty satisfying. But it's what's inside that counts, right?
They say:
Where'd ya get those peepers?Flash your lashes with our fibre-rich formulation which lengthens lashes from root to tip. Voluptuous volume and no clumps... Just a full, flirty flutter.
The wand on this mascara is a bristle-type brush with a little dip in the middle of the brush. Mine leans slightly to one side but I don't think it's intentional. I prefer a plastic comb or a brush with very sparse and short bristles.
When you pull the brush out you can see the little fibres clinging to it, ready to be deposited on the lashes.
XL picture for little fibres
I was excited to see how much lengthening these little fibres could do for my lashes, as I've heard some good things about fibre mascaras. However, when it came to actually coating my lashes I was left deeply unimpressed. On the first pass I was left asking myself whether anything at all had been deposited on my lashes. I persevered, however and built up the first coat until I got this:
BARE LASHES
WITH ONE COAT OF 17 PEEP SHOW MASCARA
The formula is decently black, but it doesn't really boost my lashes. They don't look especially lengthened, which was the main point of having the fibres in the mascara.
Nonetheless, I persevered with a second coat:
I included the front-on picture so it's obvious just how little this mascara is doing for my lashes. I felt like a second coat didn't add any length or volume, just extra spidery-ness. In it's favour, the mascara didn't clump at this point.
Just for good luck, I went for a third and final coat:
At this point I felt like my lashes just looked ugly and spidery. Length and volume were not boosted by this third coat. Again, this coat did prove just how clump-free this formula is, so that was nice.
I was curious about the mascara's lack of lengthening ability. I could forgive this mascara a lot if it was lengthening, but not giving my lashes enough 'lift' for that length to be impactful. But there seemed to be none of the little fibres adhering to my lashes. 'Maybe my lashes are fibre mascara unfriendly' I thought.
I gave the mascara a little swipe on my hand to have a closer look at the little blighters:
I was surprised when I saw this... There's only a few little fibres clinging in there! There's about three, and some mascara blobs that in the photo look a bit like fibres. This whole 'lengthening with fibres' thing isn't really going to work when there's so few fibres. It's just silly. Why bother with them in the first place? It's such a token effort that it actually makes me a bit cross.
One major plus point is that I rubbed over this swatch a few times with my finger and it did not budge. It's a pretty smudgeproof formula.
Where: Boots
How much: £6.29
You'll like: possibly if you're looking for a very bland mascara with cute packaging for a young teen.
You won't like: if you like your mascaras to have impact.
Bottom line: don't bother.